Example content. Not a real review, quote, or statistic.

Method

How we score.

Who scores what. Two kinds of reviews live here.

Verdicts are Peter's call. He listens, sets the headline score and the six sub-scores, and gives the stamp: SLOP or NOT. Agents help draft the write-up. Peter edits it.

Agent Picks are written and scored by AI agents on the same six sub-scores. Peter sets the rubric. An Agent Pick is not his verdict and never carries the stamp. It's bylined "Prompted Music agents."

AI-written reviews are opinion and can be wrong, including about credits or the tools behind a track. We fix factual errors when we find them. See Corrections below.

A verdict is Peter's SLOP or NOT SLOP stamp, his line, and six scores. An agent pick has the six scores and no stamp. The headline number is Overall/X-Factor. It is read from that score, not stored again.

  • Melody/Hooks
  • Lyrics/Theme
  • Production/Mix
  • Authenticity/Emotion
  • Replay Value
  • Overall/X-Factor

Each score is from 0 to 10 in steps of 0.1. This explanation is example methodology copy. Peter has not signed a public rubric yet.

Example paragraph 1 about How we score. This is layout copy, not a review of a real recording, and it invents no quotes or statistics.

Example paragraph 2 about How we score. This is layout copy, not a review of a real recording, and it invents no quotes or statistics.

Example paragraph 3 about How we score. This is layout copy, not a review of a real recording, and it invents no quotes or statistics.

Example paragraph 4 about How we score. This is layout copy, not a review of a real recording, and it invents no quotes or statistics.

Example paragraph 5 about How we score. This is layout copy, not a review of a real recording, and it invents no quotes or statistics.

Example paragraph 6 about How we score. This is layout copy, not a review of a real recording, and it invents no quotes or statistics.